Ta-Nehisi Coates on why stories matter in the age of Trump
by
Get the full episode insights!
Enter your email below to get notified about more insights from:
Today in Focus
This episode is titled:
Ta-Nehisi Coates on why stories matter in the age of Trump
Notable Quotes
"The material lives downstream from culture."
"It's not a writer's job to win elections."
"I don't think they believe what they say about American institutions."
Get episode summaries just like this for all your favourite podcasts in your inbox every day!
Get More InsightsEpisode Summary
In this episode, journalist and author Ta-Nehisi Coates speaks about his new book 'The Message', which examines the influence of stories on politics and society. He reflects on a 2014 essay that positioned reparations for African Americans as a necessity, a topic that recently gained renewed attention with congressional hearings on reparations. Coates discusses how the cultural narratives shaped by figures like Donald Trump resonate deeply, arguing that they reveal a profound understanding of cultural power that many on the liberal side fail to recognize. He asserts that the stories told significantly affect people's material lives, suggesting that Trump's storytelling exemplifies how politics can be shaped by cultural narratives.
Coates contrasts Trump's narratives with Barack Obama's, noting that while Obama is a gifted storyteller, he has often refrained from building a lasting political infrastructure, which leads to a disconnect between aspirational narratives and concrete societal change. He argues that America is mistaken in believing its culture is separate from its politics, suggesting instead that cultural narratives are fundamental in shaping political landscapes.
As Coates delves deeper, he critiques the responses of liberal narratives to right-wing movements and how these stories have influenced recent political dynamics. He posits that attempts to counter narratives around race and structural discrimination have often failed, giving room for more dangerous stories to take root.
Coates shares his experiences while exploring the Israel-Palestine conflict, revealing how the stories told about this issue often diverge sharply from the realities on the ground. He highlights the dominance of certain narratives over others in American media, particularly the overpowering Zionist narratives which overshadow Palestinian voices.
He concludes with advice for aspiring writers, emphasizing the importance of questioning authority and the current trend of cowardice among institutional leaders. 'The Message' serves as both a reflection on the stories shaping our reality and a call to action for a new generation of storytellers.
Coates contrasts Trump's narratives with Barack Obama's, noting that while Obama is a gifted storyteller, he has often refrained from building a lasting political infrastructure, which leads to a disconnect between aspirational narratives and concrete societal change. He argues that America is mistaken in believing its culture is separate from its politics, suggesting instead that cultural narratives are fundamental in shaping political landscapes.
As Coates delves deeper, he critiques the responses of liberal narratives to right-wing movements and how these stories have influenced recent political dynamics. He posits that attempts to counter narratives around race and structural discrimination have often failed, giving room for more dangerous stories to take root.
Coates shares his experiences while exploring the Israel-Palestine conflict, revealing how the stories told about this issue often diverge sharply from the realities on the ground. He highlights the dominance of certain narratives over others in American media, particularly the overpowering Zionist narratives which overshadow Palestinian voices.
He concludes with advice for aspiring writers, emphasizing the importance of questioning authority and the current trend of cowardice among institutional leaders. 'The Message' serves as both a reflection on the stories shaping our reality and a call to action for a new generation of storytellers.
Key Takeaways
- The crisis of storytelling in American political culture significantly shapes public perception and policy.
- Reparations for African Americans have resurfaced as a vital topic amid changing political climates.
- Donald Trump's narrative techniques leverage cultural power, while liberals often fail to engage in cultural storytelling.
- The Israel-Palestine conflict showcases a disparity between mainstream narratives and the lived experiences of those on the ground.
- Young writers should seek out environments that nurture courage and honesty, avoiding institutions led by cowardice.