The Birth Keepers: When Emilee met Yolande – episode two

In the second episode of The Birth Keepers series by The Guardian Investigates, hosts Shirin Kala and Lucy Osborne explore the histories of Emily Saldea and Yolanda Norris Clark, influential figures in the free birth movement. The discussion begins with Emily's transformation from a hula hoop performer to a leading figure advocating for free births, where she promotes birthing without medical assistance. The episode highlights Emily and Yolanda’s familial backgrounds, which are steeped in medical professions, creating a striking contrast to their current beliefs that often reject mainstream medical practices.

Emily's experiences as a doula, where she witnessed traumatic situations within the healthcare system, drove her away from traditional birthing methods. The podcast sheds light on her psychological state during these times and her subsequent radicalization against the medical establishment, which she perceived as abusive towards women. The topics cover her early work as a doula, her entrepreneurial instincts, and how the negative experiences she observed influenced her views on childbirth.

As the narrative unfolds, listeners learn how Emily stumbled across Yolanda through a podcast, leading to a partnership that would significantly influence their trajectory in the free birth advocacy. Yolanda Norris Clark's unique approach to childbirth and self-identification as a traditional birth attendant help strengthen their shared resolve. Both women developed a following based on their strong, often controversial, statements regarding childbirth practices and their fervent beliefs against medical intervention.

The engagement between the two influencers is complex, as Yolanda's initial skepticism about Emily evolves into a collaborative effort that garners millions in revenue through the creation of the Free Birth Society and educational courses about free birth. However, despite their growing influence, the episode raises questions about their actual experiences and qualifications in attending births, suggesting claims of extensive experience may be inflated. The podcast concludes with warnings about the dangers of their extreme positions on childbirth, highlighting the concerns of some followers about the repercussions of their views on maternal health care.